Bhagavad Gītā 13.24–25 — The Continuity of Sādhanā Across Births
Central enquiry
Does every sādhaka begin the journey towards mokṣa from the same point? Or does each begin from where the previous journey has left him?
Bhagavān Kṛṣṇa does not prescribe one identical sequence of spiritual disciplines for every seeker. Instead, He acknowledges differences in adhikāritvam — the preparedness of the seeker — and consequently the different means through which Self-knowledge is approached. The differences belong to the sādhaka and his preparedness, not to ultimate knowledge or liberation.
The Two Verses
Bhagavad Gītā 13.24
ध्यानेनात्मनि पश्यन्ति केचिदात्मानमात्मना ।
अन्ये साङ्ख्येन योगेन कर्मयोगेन चापरे ॥ १३.२४ ॥
dhyānenātmani paśyanti kecid ātmānam ātmanā |
anye sāṅkhyena yogena karmayogena cāpare ||
Word to Word Meaning
dhyānena – Through meditation
ātmani – In oneself, in the inner being
paśyanti – Recognise, realise
kecit – Some seekers
ātmānam – The Self
ātmanā – Through the prepared inner instrument
anye – Others
sāṅkhyena – yogena Through discriminative knowledge
karmayogena – Through Karma-yoga
ca apare – And still others
Essential meaning
Some realise the Self through meditation, others through the discipline of
discriminative knowledge, and yet others through Karma-yoga.
Bhagavad Gītā 13.25
अन्ये त्वेवमजानन्तः श्रुत्वान्येभ्य उपासते ।
तेऽपि चातितरन्त्येव मृत्युं श्रुतिपरायणाः ॥ १३.२५ ॥
anye tv evam ajānantaḥ śrutvānyebhya upāsate |
te’pi cātitaranty eva mṛtyuṃ śruti-parāyaṇāḥ ||
Word to Word Meaning
anye tu – Yet others
evam ajānantaḥ – Not knowing thus
śrutvā – Having heard
anyebhyaḥ – From others, from teachers
upāsate – Worship, contemplate, follow the discipline
te api – They too
ca atitaranti – eva Certainly cross over
mṛtyum – Death, the cycle of mortality
śruti-parāyaṇāḥ – Those devoted to what they have heard
Essential meaning
Others, who do not themselves possess this discriminative understanding,
hear the teaching from knowledgeable teachers and faithfully pursue it. They too cross beyond
mortality.
Te’pi cātitaranty eva — They too certainly cross over. Bhagavān does not exclude the less- prepared seeker from mokṣa.
A seeker may approach Vedānta with an already contemplative mind. Another may require systematic śravaṇa and manana. A third may find the mind incapable of sustained enquiry and require Karma-yoga and Upāsanā. Why this difference? The answer lies in saṃskāra, vāsanā, puṇya, and the accumulated preparedness of the antaḥkaraṇa. A new birth does not necessarily imply that the spiritual journey begins anew from the first step.
Bhagavad Gītā 6.43
तत्र तं बुद्धिसंयोगं लभते पौर्वदेहिकम् ।
यतते च ततो भूयः संसिद्धौ कुरुनन्दन ॥
tatra taṃ buddhisaṃyogaṃ labhate paurvadehikam |
yatate ca tato bhūyaḥ saṃsiddhau kurunandana ||
There he regains the connection with the understanding acquired in a previous embodiment and strives again towards perfection.
The jñāna-yogyatā cultivated in previous births can express itself as preparedness in the present birth. However, we should not equate every previous spiritual experience with established Ātma-jñāna. What continues is the causal disposition of the antaḥkaraṇa — not a travelling Ātman acquiring new qualifications. The Ātman is ever nitya-śuddha-buddha-mukta. It is the subtle body, associated with avidyā and karma, that accounts for continuity across births.
One sādhaka’s beginning may be another sādhaka’s advanced station.
Śrī Śaṅkarācārya’s Bhāṣya helps us understand the distinctions more precisely.
Dhyāna — The contemplatively prepared seeker
Śrī Śaṅkarācārya explains dhyāna in terms of an uninterrupted flow of similar mental modifications, free from intrusion by dissimilar thoughts. Such a seeker possesses the capacity for sustained contemplation. In an Advaitic progression, this may correspond to a mind ready for deep nididhyāsana and jñāna-niṣṭhā. But this does not imply that meditation independently produces liberating knowledge without the necessary pramāṇa.
Sāṅkhya-yoga — The seeker prepared for discrimination
Here sāṅkhya is understood in the Bhāṣya as the discrimination between the Self and the non-Self, not merely the independent dualistic Sāṅkhya system. Such a seeker is capable of pursuing the enquiry through śravaṇa and manana, arriving at clear knowledge of the distinction between Kṣetra and Kṣetrajña.
Karma-yoga — The seeker requiring purification
Such a seeker requires greater antaḥkaraṇa-śuddhi. By performing appropriate action without attachment to its fruits, with Īśvarārpaṇa-buddhi and prasāda-buddhi, the seeker gradually acquires the necessary preparedness for Self-enquiry. Karma-yoga is therefore a preparatory means to knowledge, not an independent producer of mokṣa.
These three approaches need not represent three entirely separate kinds of human beings. They represent different predominances of preparedness. One person may require more Karma-yoga; another more discrimination; a third sustained contemplation. Nor should we interpret the verse as establishing a rigid chronological order. The verse itself begins with dhyāna, proceeds
to sāṅkhya, and then Karma-yoga — beginning with a highly contemplative discipline and moving towards preparatory action. This supports a reading based on differing qualifications rather than one compulsory sequence.
Verse 13.25 introduces a fourth category: anye tv evam ajānantaḥ. There are those who do not yet possess the discrimination described in the preceding verses. But they hear from others: śrutvā anyebhyaḥ upāsate. They receive instruction and pursue the discipline in accordance with what they have heard.
This is a compassionate acknowledgement of śraddhā and guru-upadeśa. They may not yet possess the intellectual maturity to enquire independently into Kṣetra, Kṣetrajña, Prakṛti, Puruṣa and their ultimate truth. Yet their devotion to the teaching is not wasted. Śrī Śaṅkarācārya explains the importance of being śruti-parāyaṇa — devoted to the authoritative teaching heard from others. Such seekers too become eligible to cross mortality.
Does mere hearing or devotion directly grant mokṣa?
We must distinguish the assurance of eventual liberation from the immediate means of liberation. In Advaita, avidyā is removed by knowledge alone. Verse 13.25 need not be understood as declaring that devotional hearing without understanding independently destroys ignorance. Rather, we may unfold its implication as follows:
→ Śraddhā and Guru-upadeśa — Faithful hearing and acceptance of the teaching
→ Karma-yoga and Upāsanā — Antaḥkaraṇa-śuddhi and ekāgratā
→ Śravaṇa, Manana and Nididhyāsana — Knowledge and its firm assimilation
→ Ātma-jñāna — Mokṣa — Recognition of ever-free Ātma-svarūpa
This is an explanatory progression, not a literal sequence explicitly prescribed in verse 13.25. For some seekers, this preparation may extend across births. For others, the necessary maturity may arise within one lifetime. Bhagavad Gītā 6.44–45 further supports continuity of spiritual effort and its eventual fruition. We cannot establish from these verses precisely which stage any particular person attained in a previous birth. The teaching explains differing preparedness without requiring biographical speculation.
Certainly not. They are distinguishable disciplines, but their functioning in a sādhaka’s life can overlap.
Karma-yoga – Citta-śuddhi; addresses mala (impurity)
Upāsanā-yoga – Citta-ekāgratā; addresses vikṣepa (distraction)
Jñāna-yoga – Ātma-jñāna; addresses avidyā (ignorance)
This threefold presentation is a valuable pedagogical framework, but should not be mistaken for three mutually exclusive compartments.
- Does a seeker who commences śravaṇa cease all Karma-yoga? Not necessarily.
- Does he abandon Īśvara-upāsanā? Not necessarily.
- Does a contemplative seeker stop performing nitya-karma or serving society? Not necessarily.
The disciplines can continue to support one another. A seeker engaged in śravaṇa may still require Karma-yoga for purification of residual tendencies. Upāsanā may help steady the mind for manana and nididhyāsana. However, their functions remain distinct: Karma and Upāsanā prepare the mind; they do not replace the knowledge that removes avidyā. The practices may coexist, but their causal roles must not be confused. This distinction is central to Śrī Śaṅkarācārya’s teaching.
Bhagavad Gītā 3.1
ज्यायसी चेत्कर्मणस्ते मता बुद्धिर्जनार्दन ।
तत्किं कर्मणि घोरे मां नियोजयसि केशव ॥
jyāyasī cet karmaṇas te matā buddhir janārdana |
tat kiṃ karmaṇi ghore māṃ niyojayasi keśava ||
If knowledge is considered superior to action, why am I being directed towards action?
Bhagavad Gītā 5.1
संन्यासं कर्मणां कृष्ण पुनर्योगं च शंससि ।
यच्छ्रेय एतयोरेकं तन्मे ब्रूहि सुनिश्चितम् ॥
saṃnyāsaṃ karmaṇāṃ kṛṣṇa punar yogaṃ ca śaṃsasi |
yac chreya etayor ekaṃ tan me brūhi suniścitam ||
You praise renunciation of actions and again Karma-yoga. Tell me decisively which is better.
Both questions arise because Arjuna attempts to compare disciplines without fully appreciating the role of adhikāritvam. Bhagavān’s answer in 3.3 is particularly significant:
लोकेऽस्मिन्द्विविधा निष्ठा पुरा प्रोक्ता मयानघ ।
ज्ञानयोगेन साङ्ख्यानां कर्मयोगेन योगिनाम् ॥
loke’smin dvividhā niṣṭhā purā proktā mayānagha |
jñānayogena sāṅkhyānāṃ karmayogena yoginām ||
Two distinct niṣṭhās are taught, corresponding to the qualifications of the aspirants.
Śrī Śaṅkarācārya preserves a real distinction between Karma-niṣṭhā and Jñāna-niṣṭhā. They should not be reduced to interchangeable disciplines, nor should their results be equated. Yet the spiritual life of a seeker may involve a gradual transition from the former to the latter.
Bhagavad Gītā 5.2
तयोस्तु कर्मसंन्यासात्कर्मयोगो विशिष्यते ॥
tayos tu karmasaṃnyāsāt karmayogo viśiṣyate ||
Karma-yoga is preferable to renunciation of action for the seeker not yet adequately prepared for such renunciation.
Thus what is superior as the immediate discipline for one sādhaka need not be appropriate for another. The highest teaching remains one; the appropriate entry differs according to preparedness.
The traditional āśrama arrangement — brahmacarya, gṛhastha, vānaprastha and saṃnyāsa — provides a framework for gradual maturation. Yet spiritual maturity cannot be determined merely by the external āśrama. A gṛhastha may possess profound vairāgya and a contemplative mind. A person who has formally renounced may still require considerable antaḥkaraṇa-śuddhi.
Therefore, external āśrama and internal preparedness are not identical. However, from the standpoint of Śrī Śaṅkarācārya’s Bhāṣya, we should not say that all āśramas are doctrinally interchangeable in their relationship to Jñāna-niṣṭhā. He gives particular importance to
saṃnyāsa as the natural expression of complete renunciation and exclusive establishment in knowledge.
- External order: The disciplines and duties associated with one’s āśrama.
- Internal maturity: The degree of vairāgya, śama, dama, titikṣā, śraddhā and samādhāna.
- Ultimate recognition: Ātma-jñāna, which is not produced by an āśrama or an action.
Thus, the āśrama system provides an order of living, but it does not mechanically determine the precise spiritual maturity of every individual. The appropriate transition must be governed by adhikāritvam, śāstra and the guidance of the Guru.
From the standpoint of the empirical individual, preparation may extend over countless births.
बहूनां जन्मनामन्ते ज्ञानवान्मां प्रपद्यते ।
वासुदेवः सर्वमिति स महात्मा सुदुर्लभः ॥
bahūnāṃ janmanām ante jñānavān māṃ prapadyate |
vāsudevaḥ sarvam iti sa mahātmā sudurlabhaḥ ||
At the culmination of many births, the wise person recognises Vāsudeva as all.
But what is accumulated over these births? Not Brahman. Not the Self. Not liberation itself. What matures is the antaḥkaraṇa, until it becomes capable of recognising the truth unfolded by the
śāstra.
- From the standpoint of sādhanā: There may be gradual purification and preparation across births.
- From the standpoint of jñāna: Ignorance is removed through knowledge, not through accumulation of spiritual actions.
- From the standpoint of pāramārthika-satyam: There was never an actually bound Ātman travelling through births towards liberation.
The entire journey belongs to the apparent jīva under avidyā. The Self neither begins the journey nor reaches its destination.
The concluding Vicāra — Many stations, one destination
Some begin with meditation. Some with discrimination. Some with Karma-yoga. Others begin simply by listening to the words of a teacher, without yet understanding their full significance. The difference is not in the ultimate truth, but in the preparedness of the seeker.
A sādhaka may have cultivated purity in previous births, another steadiness, and yet another mature discrimination. Their present journeys need not commence from an identical point. Nor must Karma, Upāsanā and Jñāna-yoga be treated as watertight chronological compartments.
They can overlap in the life of the seeker, while retaining distinct functions. The āśramas too must be understood with sensitivity to internal maturity, without overlooking their śāstric distinctions.
Te’pi cātitaranty eva mṛtyum — They too certainly cross beyond mortality. Not because every discipline independently destroys ignorance, but because no sincere movement towards the truth is spiritually wasted. Properly guided, preparation culminates in the knowledge that alone removes avidyā.
The apparent journey may span many births. The culmination is the recognition of that which has never travelled. Many beginnings. Many disciplines. Many apparent stages. One knowledge. One ever-free Ātman.
A subtle point for further enquiry
Śrī Śaṅkarācārya’s distinction between dhyāna and sāṅkhya in 13.24 should not be collapsed too quickly into nididhyāsana versus śravaṇa. The correlation is pedagogically helpful, but the Bhāṣya’s exact meanings and the question of whether these are independent means or stages of preparation merit a separate close examination. This strengthens fidelity to Advaita-siddhānta.
Sadā Śrī Śaṅkara Smaraṇam
Madhavan Shankaranarayanan











